RP Ratings

[tanaka]

I am not sure we were doing this or not .. but I did it anyhow ..
not that it matters what I think .. if you don't want this here take it down please .
if I offended anyone .. remember it is only my opinion
scores are out of 20

O'Malley 16
Kingpin 16.25
Luger 14
Kautuai 15
Rameriz 12.5
Aaron Christopher 13
Hiro Tanaka did not score
Steele .. well .. I think we now this one

[Kingpin]

0n a 1-10 Scale


O'Malley 7
Kingpin -
Luger 8.5
Kau tui 8
Rameriz 6
Aaron Christopher 6
Hiro Tanaka 6
Steele 0




I really thought that TL rp'ed the best last week hands down. BUT then again I am a fan of h is work alot. Katu rp'ed really well as did O'Malley. I can defenately see fome crossing of the story lines between myself and O'Malley. we will just have to wait and see

[Rob Blondie]

rating people's RP's got me more heat in DCW than just about anything I've done...well, short of my first round as TWF Prez. So, I wont touch this idea with Dragz reproductive organs.

[Eno Redrum]

See, I know you loved Dragzilla. I am starting to think Dragzilla is as big as Mike Jones because his/her/its name is always on your mouth. KISS, KISS! LoL!

How ya been Mr. Blondie? And Happy belated birthday, although I sent you a PM on your birthday.

[Tommy "Southpaw" O'Malley]

I already PM-ed Patrick earlier. Then I realized everyone was doing this on the boards.

Looks like everyone is rating RP quality.

I did overall rankings; here goes.

katu tui 1
kingpin 2
hiro tanaki 3
Luger 4
Emilio ramirez 5
Aaron Christopher 6
Sampson Steele 7


not ranking tommy

Its interesting how people rank others*. You can tell who likes what kind of style of RPs by the rankings.

When you try to go "outside the box" in Rping I think quality is degraded when you start to hit the lines of kayfabe. If you go outside the box with creativity by staying away from kayfabe, it just starts to make more sense and a better story.

[Eno Redrum]

I know Eno and Shaka didnt have matches but someone show some love and rank their RPs. LoL

[Tomas Luger]

I, like O'Malley, already sent P.Mart my rankings and ratings. Here are mine, for you amusement:

rated from 8-1 on a 10 point scale. I took into consideration not only RP quality, but extra work like segments, introducing a storyline (not just cutting a wrestling "promo"), angles and grammar, spelling and so on.

8. Steele 0pts

7. Ramirez 6pts

6. Tanaka 6pts

5. Christopher 6pts

4. Tomas Luger 7pts

3.Katu Tui 7.5pts

2.Tommy O'Malley 8pts

1. Kingpin 8.5pts

5-7 all scored the same amount of pts in my book and the rankings are based on personal preference and future output that I can guage off of 2 RPs

I'm a mark for good Kingpin, and this was some strong stuff from him. On the flipside, sometimes Ray tries to be too creative and ends up hurting himself. This was, however, the perfect opener for him and it showed in his work.

Tommy is going to be a tough, consistant competitor from week to week and I think 8 is probably his low score.

Tui's Island Jammin is simply awesome. I had the Tomas Luger Variety Show during my stinit in the TWF and not only was it fun for me to write, but it was pretty popular if I'm not mistaken. I felt, personally, that I out RP'd Tui this week but he out worked me overall and is therefore ranked higher. Nice work, by the way, Katu. If I were P.Mart I'd've given you the W this week for sure.

Otherwise, I think this is just everyone knocking the rust off so...my opinion.

[katutui]

I guess I'll go with my scale here...


1. Tommy O'Malley, while the rest of us seemed to be knocking off the rust and trying to figure a way to out rp our opponents...Tommy went right ahead and grabbed our attention by being consistent, if he continues to do this, I'm afraid there might be no stopping him.

2. Kingpin, his rps are very interesting, but I kind of wanted to hear more about the story of killing a man to win the title, that would have been a good intimidating factor. I did enjoy his rps.

3. Thomas Luger, entertaining, funny, made me work a little harder to rp against him. I'm still working with some rp formats to find a style that suits me. TL made me work (but I still have some rust)

4. Aaron Christopher, while I don't believe that was his best effort, I'm sure he like most of us had some rp rust. Its always hard to start something going in a new fed, in a month or two another AC-Chef match might be more entertaining on the rp boards.

5. Hiro Tanaka, short, to the point, and basically trash talk, how a RP SHOULD be without all the fluff and buff if you know what I mean.

6. The Angry Chef, I don't know much about this guy's skill but I believe that he could have put a better effort into his rps, however, the mental image of plates falling to the floor and shattering is still in my head almost a week later so I guess he's not too bad.

7. Steele....oh Sampson oh Sampson where are thou oh Sampson??


I didn't rate myself since I never do.


A couple side notes, Eno Redum (which is Murder One backwards if anyone else noticed lol) was entertaining and I'm glad we're getting some insight to to he is before he has actual matches, JahMon is entertaining and makes me laugh, even the Wizard dude is entertaining although I'm not sure where he's going with these rps....nice to see good effort and material from those NOT in a match and I believe that if you don't have a match you should use that time to further an angle or show some insight to your character with at least 1 rp in 2 weeks, but that's just me I don't run the place.

All in all its a good start to a fed, a lot of times these places start up then just die after a couple of months, but with the 2 week format and the easygoing 1 rp a week requirement, its a little easier to ease into the fed and not feel like Martin is demanding us to work our butts off.

Good Job guys, looking forward to the next 2 weeks.